| Platinum | Honey Dew Donuts |
| Gold | Nickey's Pizza |
| Silver | Super Seven Subs & Pizza |
| Bronze | Pamino's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Earl of Sandwich |
| Top Pick | Primo Pizza & Roast Beef |
| Top Pick | Prince Pizzeria & Bar |
| Top Pick | The Wardhurst Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Townhouse of Pizza |
