| Platinum | Old Tyme Italian Cuisine |
| Gold | Monte's Restaurant |
| Silver | Capone's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Ciao Cafe & Bistro |
| Top Pick | Alfredo's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Demainos |
| Top Pick | Lido Cafe |
| Top Pick | Petrillo's Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Rossetti Restaurant of Lynn |
| Top Pick | Victor's Italian Restaurant |
